Friday, January 4, 2013

These Three (1936): It's a Lie! (or Is It?)

In many cases films of 1930's American cinema are very stylized, by that I mean they fall very squarely into a specific genre. Astaire/Rogers musicals follow a formula of boy meets girl meets dancing (charming boy, lovely girl, amazing dancing mind you). Shirley Temple movies were just that, perky Temple plunked down in the middle of a sweet and sentimental situation. Gangster thrillers were tough guys with tough talk and a lot of bullots in between. Much of the acting was over the top (wonderfully so in most cases) and many of the characters even more animated.

The collaboration of producer Samuel Goldwyn with director William Wyler created films during this period that, unlike the mainstream themed picture, were independent in spirit, exceptional in technical expertise. The first of the Goldwyn/Wyler successes was a very sophisticated adult drama called These Three (1936). Both powerful and compelling, the film was based on Lillian Hellman's debut play, The Children's Hour, a gripping look at the consequences surrounding a child's lie that her two schoolmistresses are lesbian lovers. Goldwyn bought the film rights to the play aware that the Hays board of Hollywood censors would never allow him to use either its title or its sapphic storyline. However, he hedged his bets by also hiring Hellman to write the screenplay. The lesbian angle was changed from sexual relations between the two female teachers to a heterosexual love triangle with one teacher allegedly committing an indescretion with the other's intended, a local doctor.


Hellman's play was partially based on a court case in 19th century Scotland and on Broadway it ran for 691 performances. It was a real heavy hitter and even with a somewhat "sanitized" version set for movie audiences, it packed a wallop as Hellman successfully tried to illustrate that the power of the story came from the damage a lie can create rather than the nature of the lie. The cast was headed by screen stars who would become Goldwyn regulars. Karen Wright and Martha Dobie, the slandered teaching duo were played by Merle Oberon and Miriam Hopkins respectively, while Joel McCrea was cast as the third leg of the titular triangle. All three gave fine performances, Hopkins and Oberon arguably the best of their careers. The physical and personality differances between "these two" complemented the picture. If Oberon had been paired with Kay Francis or Hopkins with Carole Lombard, there might have been an imbalance of sorts. Saying this however, it seems less likely that Oberon's elegant, soft spoken Karen and Hopkins earthy and somber Martha would become bosom chums as undergrads.

The supporting cast is outstanding. Catherine Doucet as Martha's worthless leech of an aunt. Marcia Mae Jones as a timid pupil, terrorized into complicity of the lie. Margaret Hamilton, whose small but notable role as a maid won't be forgotten. Alma Kruger as wealthy matron, Mrs. Tilford, whose influence in the community causes the downfall of the reputation of those involved and juvenille actress Bonita Granville. As the prepubescent monster Mary Tilford, Granville was as evil a villain as 30's audiences had experienced, giving Basil Rathbone, Lionel Atwill or Conrad Veidt a run for their sinister money. Her natural blond hair was darkened to convey a more threatening persona, but her strong performance required no such physical pretense and she was nominated at age 13 for a Best Supporting Actress Oscar, the first year the Academy offered the award (Gale Sondergaard won the prize that year).


The movie met critical acclaim including Britain's Graham Green who wrote: "I have seldom been so moved by any fictional film as by These Three. After 10 minutes or so of the usual screen sentiment, quaintness and exaggeration, one began to watch with incredulous pleasure nothing less than life." William Wyler remade the film 25 years later under its original title and with the original lesbian theme intact (and with Miriam Hopkins in the supporting role of Aunt Lily). It was a pale comparison to the '36 version, Wyler's direction and Hopkins' presence notwithstanding.

9 comments:

  1. Another enjoyable post and interesting info on what made Hellman tick. what motivated him. Also, your post made me realize I have not seen The Children's Hour. That's embarrassing to admit but I've now added it to my list.

    All the best in 2013.
    Page

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oops!
    I think I referred to Lillian as a male.
    Page

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks Page. I've always enjoying this film MUCH more than the later version.
    Happy New Year!

    Rupert

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's been a long time since I've seen this one and need to revisit it. I honestly like this better than "The Children's Hour" simply because I think I like the cast better.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It's not one that shows up a lot on TV Jessica, but worth the search if one can find it. It's always been one of my favorites from the 1930's.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Welcome back! (Good news for classic movie blog readers!) THESE THREE is very good, but I think later version of THE CHILDREN'S HOUR is a more powerful adaptation--though I know I'm in the minority among classic movie fans.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you very much Rick, it is so good to hear from you. I hope that time and circumstances will allow me to make many more additions to the blog in 2013. That is the plan anyway with a long list of potential posts already in the works.

    Although I much prefer THESE THREE, I agree THE CHILDREN'S HOUR has more emotional punch. I think that may be because the subject matter is so much more taboo and film making at the time had a more realistic tone. Regardless, they are both interesting films.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Rupert - So glad you're back to blogging. Thanks for a great piece on a classic. I prefer "These Three," the McCrea/Hopkins/Oberon/Granville combination is unbeatable - though I think Shirley MacLaine was very strong in "The Children's Hour." I also wish the original film been able to keep the lesbian accusation in the story. That damned Code! I watched "These Three" for the first time in many years not so long ago and thought it held up well.

    ReplyDelete
  9. In a perfect world, this cast would have performed the 60s script. Still, there is something so compelling about this version. And those kids - mean girls in the making! Great post - very enjoyable read.

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails